County leaders acknowledge EMS critical condition

Clarion County Director of Emergency Services Jeff Smathers, left, and Clarion County Commissioner Ed Heasley discuss possible solutions to the EMS crisis facing the county.

CLARION - "We are all in a critical situation," said Clarion County Commissioner Ed Heasley Nov. 15.

That critical situation is the dwindling number of ambulance personnel and ambulance services especially in rural areas.

"We must work together so the residents and visitors to Clarion County don't receive the message "We will send the next available unit' during an emergency call," Heasley said.

But that is exactly what happened for two months last summer.

"During those two months we were uncovered more than we were covered," said Steve Merryman of Shippenville Ambulance Service.

Jeff Smathers, Clarion County's Director of Emergency Services, said that when a call for an ambulance is received the call is directed to the nearest ambulance service.

"If that service can't crew, then the call is directed to another service," Smathers explained.

Smathers said that there are five services in the county but in reality only four are usually available and sometimes only three to cover the entire county.

Smathers said when an ambulance is on a call outside of their own service area it creates a vacuum.

"There were six times last year when every ambulance was committed," Smathers recalled. "When that happens we have to pull from another county. They have the same problem. That creates a void there and they are reluctant to uncover their own county. They do send them however. Of course we do the same for them.

Smathers said it is a "collective" problem. He said it is difficult to attract emergency medical technicians because the pay in rural areas does not compare to the rate paid in urban areas.

Smathers said the second problem is the reimbursement rate for an ambulance call is limited.

"They could make a call and bill Medicare $1,200 and get reimbursed just $200," Smathers said, noting private insurers pay more but there are few of them in the area.

Merryman said the Shippenville service increased the pay rate for its EMTs to $12.50 an hour and the rate for paramedics from $13 an hour to $16 just to get crews.

Heasley, a firefighter for many years, said that to provide a full-time, 24/7 crew and equipment, would cost approximately $400,000 - $500,000 per year, per unit.

Merryman said that to compound the problem the ambulance services must also pay their own workmen's compensation insurance.

Smathers said many of the EMTs and paramedics work 24-hour shifts, which allows them to work for more than one service.

"In the end they get burned out," he said.

Clarion County has entered into an agreement with the state Department of Community and Economic development to conduct a study of the need for both emergency medical and fires services. The survey is at no cost to the county.

The county also formed the Clarion County Emergency Medical Service Task Force to work with municipal governments with a goal of finding a solution to the crisis.

"The issues we are facing within Clarion County are not just local but something that is hitting the entire commonwealth," said Heasley. "We must build a partnership to address the current problems and challenges facing us today."

Potential remedies

There are several short-term remedies and the possibility of a long-term fix. There may be relief at the local level.

"Every municipality is responsible for providing fire and EMS protection," said Smathers. "The county cannot do this."

Smathers said Pennsylvania Acts 7, 8 and 9 mandate the municipality shall be responsible for ensuring that fire and EMS are provided to the extent determined by the municipality, including financial and administrative assistance for the services.

Often that support takes the shape of a financial donation.

Karen Best, secretary for Licking and Piney townships said the service does not ask for a set amount of money.

"They need to have their ducks in a row when they come to the township and ask for money," Best said. "We might think we are doing something great when we give them a thousand dollars when they probably think we are being cheap. They need to communicate with us."

Many of the townships that do not have a service within their boundaries will have a memorandum of agreement with a nearby service.

Smathers said the townships could authorize an EMS tax.

Merryman said money generated from that tax would not be sufficient.

"The tax is on the same people who are already paying," he said. "We increased the pay for the EMTs and paramedics just to get them to stay with us. We knew we would be going another $10,000 in the hole every year."

Long-term aid may come from the state.

Heasley said there are two bills under consideration in the Pennsylvania Legislature. House Bill 1322 would allow an optional sales tax for property relief and municipal assistance.

"By levying a 1 percent sales tax as a tool to improve core services that are beneficial to our communities we would help police, firefighters, EMS, public works and administrative services," said Heasley.

Heasley said the potential problem would be that the money raised by the new levy would be sent to Harrisburg and then disbursed to the local agencies.

"Harrisburg would assess an administrative fee and we have no idea how large that fee would be," said Heasley. "That would mean less money sent back to the agencies that really need the money."

The second bill is Senate Bill 698. Heasley said this bill would allow for the creation of public safety authorities like water authorities.

"The municipality would step up and work with their local providers," said Heasley.

Smathers said that Rep. Donna Oberlander and Sen. Scott Hutchinson have indicated support for the bills.

Smathers said local education centers are helping.

"Clarion County Career Center and Clarion University have stepped up to bat," he said. "The Career Center is excited about it and the university has set up a feeder program. We hope that if kids get excited about EMS or firefighting they might continue after graduation."

The task force will meet again at 3 p.m. Dec. 27 in the Clarion County Administration building in Clarion.

"It will take everyone to figure this out," said Heasley.


WASHINGTON TWP. - A citizens' push for Washington Township to have its own webpage was broached a few times in 2021 and in the first meeting of 2022 the Washington Township Board of Supervisors moved one step closer to making a web presence a reality.

SHIPPENVILLE - Fixing a broken drain pipe can be a chore for any road crew but to have a lone maintenance worker accomplish the repair along one of the busiest stretches of two-lane highway in the county during the winter is just a bit much for the Shippenville Borough Council to approve.

CLARION - When it was announced at the Clarion Area School Board work session Jan 4. the Clarion administration was seriously looking into creating a middle school for sixth-, seventh- and eighth-grades to be in operation as early as the fall of 2022, the plan got some pushback from members …

ELK TWP. - The Elk Township Board of Supervisors began 2022 by welcoming two new supervisors Les Wingard began a six-year term and John S. Knight Sr. began a two-year term.

CLARION - The number of influenza cases in Clarion County increased again according to the latest report from the Pennsylvania Department of Health.

CLARION - Clarion County will host an unusual race this summer adventure racing. "We have a new event coming to Clarion County called Rootstalk Racing," said Clarion Chamber of Business and Industry Executive Director Tracy Becker.

PAINT TWP. - An increased effort to keep people out of jail and factors related to the COVID-19 emergency led to the Clarion County Jail coming about 13 percent -- $329,611 under budget.

When winter weather comes barreling in, it comes in hard. These two photographs of Main Street in Clarion were taken about 24 hours apart. One was taken Sunday morning and the other was taken Monday morning as the county began digging out from a foot of snow in some places. More snow was for…

FARMINGTON — A Jan. 12 investigation and search warrant execution at a Farmington Township camp turned up about $20,000 worth of fentanyl, methamphetamine and crack cocaine, according to the Clarion County District Attorney's Office.

The National Weather Service in Pittsburgh has issued a Winter Storm Warning from 1 p.m. Sunday to 1 p.m. Monday for most of western Pennsylvania including Venango, Clarion, Mercer, Forest, Jefferson, and Butler counties.

KNOX - The Knox Volunteer Fire Department can trace its roots back to the 1870s, according to information compiled by department chief Matthew Yeager.

CLARION - Clarion County officials are looking to Harrisburg for the "authority to create an authority." If legislation is adopted in Harrisburg, local municipalities could from an authority to deal with the crisis in emergency medical services.

CLARION - Over the years, there has been one item on the Clarion Area administration's proverbial backburner which needed addressed and at the Clarion Area School Board work session Jan. 4 and Clarion Superintendent Dr. Joseph Carrico took the matter head on.

CLARION - The Clarion County Board of Commissioners Dec. 28 took the first step toward a full, physical, assessment of all properties in the county. That step was the employment of International Association of Assessing Officers at a cost of $50,000.

FRILLS CORNERS - It has been a period of uncertainty for the Lake Lucy Municipal Authority in recent months but the Washington Township Board of Supervisors took steps Dec. 27 toward solving the problems.

LAMARTINE - Salem Township supervisors Dec. 27 gave their final approval to a $285,300 budget for 2022, balancing the spending plan without a tax increase.

HARRISBURG - For the second consecutive year, Clarion County townships and boroughs face another reduction in their state liquid fuels road funding, albeit this year's reduction is far less than last year's COVID-related cuts.

CLARION - The hallways at the Clarion County Community Action building in Clarion are lined with donated food items. That is because the small office building is also the Clarion Food Pantry.

ELK TWP. - "People really don't know how dire the situation is," Elk Township Supervisor Ray Rennard said this month, speaking of the struggles Clarion County ambulance services are facing.

CLARION - On Jan. 4, for the first time in almost 40 years, Rex Munsee will not be carrying a badge. When Sheriff-elect Shawn Zerfoss is sworn in, Munsee will be a civilian.

CLARION - The Clarion County bi-annual judicial tax sale last week more than met expectations. The sale generated a total of $254,908.

CLARION - Clarion Borough and Clarion Township might get a "do-over" on the 2020 census count that showed population drops taking both municipalities under important funding thresholds.

CLARION - As COVID-19 case numbers continue to climb in Clarion County, so too, do the number of cases of influenza reported to the state Department of Health.

KNOX - The Keystone School Board Dec. 20 approved the implementation of a revised health and safety plan and/or a potential communicable disease prevention and control plan.

CLARION - Christmas is a time for traditions but those traditions change over the years. One hundred years ago, Christmas 1921, was celebrated very differently than the way the holiday is observed in 2021.

CLARION - As the winter season sets in and the COVID-19 emergency continues to sweep through the area, the state Department of Health reports influenza cases are on the rise.

KNOX - The Keystone School Board Dec. 8 tentatively agreed to cap any real estate tax increase for the upcoming 2022-23 school year to no more than 4.9 percent, or 2.52 mills.

CLARION - The holidays are a busy time of the year and no one is busier than Santa Claus. The jolly old Elf took a few minutes off from his hectic schedule to give the Oil City Derrick an exclusive interview.

FOXBURG - When the Allegheny-Clarion Valley and Union School districts entered into a football co-op in 2016, it was just the football teams that combined but now one A-C Valley resident would like to see one of the mainstays of Friday night football games merge as well.

CLARION - Clarion Borough Council Dec. 7 gave its tentative approval to its 2022 general fund budget totaling $2,508,350. The budget does not call for any tax increases.

KNOX - Just one month after the general election filled a two-year term council seat for 2022, Knox Borough Council finds it will need a person to fill that seat after all.

CLARION - For this feature, the most recent week of reporting to the state Department of Health Nov. 23 through 29 the number of COVID-19 cases by local Zip Code included:

FOXBURG - Over the course of time, things are bound to need upgrades here and there and according to some community members, the football field on the A-C Valley campus is in dire need of an upgrade.